The Visa Queue
Live
Policy

Lawsuit Targets Federal Voter Initiative Over Naturalized Citizen Rights

Civil rights groups have sued to halt a federal program investigating the voting eligibility of naturalized citizens, alleging it uses flawed data to conduct improper investigations and risks disenfranchising thousands.

Civil rights groups have sued to halt a federal program investigating the voting eligibility of naturalized citizens...

Four civil rights and voting groups sued the federal government on October 28, 2026. They are challenging the 'Unlawful Voter Initiative,' a program launched by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) in August 2026. The case, numbered 3:26-cv-12617, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. It alleges the initiative has subjected thousands of naturalized U.S. citizens to improper investigations.

Background

The initiative cross-references citizenship and voter registration data to identify noncitizens who may have voted unlawfully. It relies on sections of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), including § 237(a)(3)(D)(i) and § 237(a)(6)(A), which address voting by aliens. The program has drawn sharp criticism from major advocacy organizations. The ACLU Voting Rights Project, Common Cause, and OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates are among the plaintiffs. Local chapters like OCA-San Mateo and OCA-Sacramento are also involved.

Lawsuit Details

The lawsuit aims to stop the Unlawful Voter Initiative entirely. It seeks a court order to block the government from withholding or discarding valid ballots based on its findings. The plaintiffs demand a declaratory judgment that the program violates the Civil Rights Act, the Privacy Act, and the Administrative Procedure Act. They argue the initiative operates without proper legal authority and safeguards.

Impact

Critics say the initiative's methods lead to door-to-door interrogations and potential disenfranchisement. They contend federal agents use outdated and error-prone government data. In some instances, agents have posed as individual voters to search private voter registration records. The flawed data has reportedly flagged thousands of lawful citizens. In one example, the initiative identified 20,000 registered voters for review but found only 400 suspected noncitizens.

Reaction

The Department of Homeland Security, which oversees USCIS, is named in the suit alongside Secretary Markwayne Mullin. Mullin has publicly defended the program's goal. He stated, "American elections are for Americans only." Former USCIS Director Joseph Edlow launched the initiative. U.S. Senate Democrats have criticized the effort. Theresa J. Lee of the ACLU Voting Rights Project accused the government of "challenging voters and threatening states." The initiative is active in nine states. The lawsuit aims to stop the Unlawful Voter Initiative and seeks to block withholding or discarding valid ballots.

Related coverage

More from Policy