The Visa Queue
Live
Policy

Court Blocks Afghan Deportation Flights to Pakistan

A federal judge issued a temporary restraining order halting the planned removal of detained Afghan nationals to Afghanistan or Pakistan through November 7, 2026.

A federal judge issued a temporary restraining order halting the planned removal of detained Afghan nationals to...

A federal judge in New York has temporarily blocked the planned removal of detained Afghan nationals to Afghanistan or Pakistan. The order, issued by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, remains in effect through Saturday, November 7, 2026.

Judge Caproni issued the temporary restraining order on November 3. It halts any deportation flights for the duration of its validity. The order followed government assurances that no such flights were scheduled. The administration had considered transporting nearly 200 Afghan nationals from Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody to Pakistan before sending them overland to Afghanistan.

Government Representation on Flight Plans

Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials told the court there were no planned or confirmed charter or commercial flights for deporting Afghan nationals to Afghanistan or Pakistan during the order's validity. Deputy Assistant Director for Enforcement and Removal Operations Christopher George made this representation through counsel. The government stated that arranging such deportation flights takes weeks. A specific charter flight had been originally scheduled to depart from Alexandria, Louisiana, on November 3, with Pakistan listed as the destination for onward transport to Afghanistan.

The court order directs officials to comply with these representations. It temporarily blocks removals, not only a specific flight schedule. The Department of Homeland Security has declined to discuss prospective removal operations, citing operational security and personnel safety.

Detainee Impact and Advocacy Response

More than 80 detained Afghans contacted advocates after receiving ICE removal notices. This group does not represent everyone covered by the court order. The detainees included women, a police officer, members of religious minorities, and people with relatives who served in the U.S. military. Advocacy groups Human Rights First and AfghanEvac stated most detainees had fled persecution and lacked legal representation.

Advocates warn of grave risks upon return to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan. Savitri Arvey, policy director at Human Rights First, said people returned face systematic dangers including arbitrary detention, executions, public flogging, and retaliatory violence. The proposed transfers involved at least one gay man and others who supported U.S. military operations, raising specific persecution concerns. Shawn VanDiver, president of AfghanEvac, described the court-ordered pause as a reprieve, not a resolution.

Congressional and Diplomatic Concerns

A letter signed by 66 members of Congress was sent to Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin on November 2, 2026. It urged the cancellation of deportation flights involving Afghans, warning of risks of persecution, torture, or death. California Representative Scott Peters, who led the letter, said sending these individuals to the Taliban breaks a national promise to those who risked their lives for the U.S.

Afghanistan's Taliban-led Foreign Ministry also expressed serious concern about the reported transfers through Pakistan. Deputy spokesman Zia Ahmad Takal confirmed this diplomatic unease. The Pakistani embassy did not immediately respond to requests for comment. U.S. authorities cannot conduct direct deportations to Afghanistan due to the suspension of operations at the Kabul embassy in 2021 and the lack of diplomatic relations with the Taliban.

Legal Challenges and Uncertain Future

Parallel legal challenges emerged in Texas and Louisiana courts for individual detainees. In one case, a judge ordered the release of 30-year-old Afghan national Said Mansor Sadat, ruling his detention violated due process. He was removed from the flight list. Other cases involved detainees Basir Ahmad Ahmadi and Khaled Khaleeq.

The court order does not resolve what will happen to the affected detainees after November 7, 2026. ICE told some detainees the flight had been postponed for one or two weeks. Shawn VanDiver of AfghanEvac noted the temporary victory, stating that a planned plane a week ago was now denied by the government in court. The Department of Homeland Security has defended its third-country deportation policy, stating that individuals receive notice and assurances before removal. The order is set to expire on November 7, 2026, leaving the long-term fate of the detainees uncertain.

Topics

#Policy

Related coverage

More from Policy