The Visa Queue
Live
Policy

Lawsuit Challenges IRS Sharing of Immigrant Taxpayer Data with ICE

A federal lawsuit alleges the IRS improperly shared protected taxpayer records with immigration enforcement agencies, a practice a judge halted after 47,000 records were transferred.

A federal lawsuit alleges the IRS improperly shared protected taxpayer records with immigration enforcement agencies, a...

A federal judge halted U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement's practice of accessing 47,000 immigrant taxpayer records, ruling the data transfer violated privacy laws. Immigrant-rights advocates filed a federal lawsuit in September 2026 to investigate whether the Internal Revenue Service improperly shared protected taxpayer records with ICE and the Department of Homeland Security, including a transfer of hundreds of thousands of Social Security records in March 2025.

Lawsuit Challenges IRS's Role in Deportation Data Transfers

Advocates filed the federal lawsuit on September 9-10, 2026. It challenges the IRS's role in a deportation effort and seeks records about the Social Security Administration's transfer of hundreds of immigrants' information to DHS in March 2025. The motions also ask whether the government is using contractors like ThunderCat and Palantir to obtain taxpayer information despite a court order. The dispute involves tens of thousands of taxpayer records.

The September motions were filed by legal groups on behalf of several immigrant advocacy organizations. The tax records include information from people who use Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers because they cannot obtain Social Security numbers. The tax agency had previously assured ITIN holders their information would not be shared for immigration enforcement.

Government Claims All Records Belonged to Individuals with Final Removal Orders

At an October 7, 2026, First Circuit hearing, Justice Department attorney Jacob Christensen stated that all 47,000 people whose information was shared had final orders of removal. He said they had all passed the 90-day deadline to depart the country. The government's position treats remaining in the country after a removal deadline as a possible basis for a criminal investigation.

This stance has faced judicial scrutiny. Judge Seth Aframe questioned whether a removal order alone could support a criminal investigation, comparing it to treating every driver as potentially under investigation for lacking auto insurance. Judge Julie Rikelman pointed to the initial request's inclusion of people who had not passed the 90-day period, asking how there could be a good faith belief that a crime had been committed.

Critics Argue Mass Data Requests Violate Privacy Protections

Several senior IRS officials, including the acting commissioner and chief privacy officers, resigned in protest of the data-sharing agreement. They argued it likely violated privacy laws. The law allows disclosure only for qualifying criminal investigations, with the government relying on an exception in Section 6103 of the tax code for non-tax criminal investigations. Joshua Rosenthal of the Asian Law Caucus, attorney for the lead plaintiff, stated that the law requires a 'meaningful' investigation. He argued that requests covering 1.2 million people could not meet that standard.

In summer 2025, immigration officials initially sought addresses for 1.28 million people. A judicial panel later noted the same contact person was listed for every request involving those 1.28 million taxpayers. Judge Cornelia Pillard wrote that the tax agency had not required a 'specific reason' connecting requested records to a qualifying investigation.

The data-sharing has had a chilling effect. The Community Economic Development Center reported that membership and attendance fell as noncitizens feared disclosure. Rogelio, a 42-year-old Mexican immigrant, stopped filing taxes in 2018 due to fear of ICE arrest and now saves money to repay back taxes. Nina Olson, executive director of the Center for Taxpayer Rights and a former senior tax agency official, called the data-sharing move 'unprecedented' and a 'gross violation of privacy'.

Key FigureDetail
Records shared before halt47,000 immigrant taxpayer records
Initial ICE request in summer 2025Addresses for 1.28 million people
Undocumented immigrant tax contributionEstimated $59 billion annually
Potential revenue loss from 1% compliance dropRoughly $46 billion
Social Security trust fund depletion warningBy late 2032 without congressional action

Immigrants using ITINs pay an estimated $59 billion annually into federal programs including Social Security and Medicare but are ineligible to receive benefits. More than a third of the taxes paid by undocumented immigrants goes to those programs. About 85% of taxpayers comply voluntarily. A one-percentage-point decline in compliance could mean roughly $46 billion in uncollected revenue.

Court rulings have created a complex legal landscape. District Judge Dabney Friedrich denied a temporary restraining order on March 20, 2025. In May 2025, the court denied a preliminary injunction, concluding the tax code likely allowed address sharing for criminal investigations but not civil enforcement. The D.C. Circuit affirmed that denial in February 2026. On February 5, 2026, two federal courts had barred further sharing under the agreement, and ICE was barred from using data it had received. A U.S. appeals court in Washington, D.C. upheld the ban on IRS-ICE data sharing in September 2026. The administration has provided only a heavily redacted record of the Social Security Administration's data transfer. As of October 23, 2026, the groups' September motions are still seeking information about the Social Security transfer and possible contractor access. The First Circuit Court will hear arguments on whether the government's use of tax records for immigration enforcement violates privacy laws.

Related coverage

More from Policy