The Visa Queue
Live
Policy

Green Card Holder Appeals Detention for Pro-Palestine Protest

Lawful permanent resident Mahmoud Khalil asks the Supreme Court to review a ruling that bars federal courts from hearing his challenge to detention for campus activism, testing First Amendment protections for noncitizens.

Lawful permanent resident Mahmoud Khalil asks the Supreme Court to review a ruling that bars federal courts from hearing...

Mahmoud Khalil, a lawful permanent resident and former Columbia University graduate student, petitioned the Supreme Court on October 19, 2026, to review a ruling that blocks federal district judges from hearing his challenge to immigration detention. The Algerian citizen, born in 1995 in a Palestinian refugee camp in Syria, was arrested by immigration agents in Manhattan on March 8, 2025, and detained for 104 days in Louisiana. He was taken from the student housing complex he shared with his U.S. citizen wife shortly after graduating.

Legal challenges and court rulings

A federal judge ordered Khalil's release from Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody in June 2025. That decision was overturned in January 2026 by a 2-1 panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The appellate court ruled that immigration law requires Khalil to raise his claims through the immigration system, barring district court review before those proceedings conclude. An expanded panel of the same court upheld that reversal by a narrow 6-5 vote in May 2026. Three dissenting judges warned the decision could imperil the civil liberties of Khalil and similarly situated noncitizens.

The 3rd Circuit has paused its ruling, maintaining a temporary order that bars the government from re-detaining Khalil while his Supreme Court petition is pending. His separate removal order, which lists Algeria or Syria as potential destinations, is under appeal at the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals. Written arguments in that case are expected to conclude in early November.

The free speech argument

Secretary of State Marco Rubio invoked an obscure provision of the Immigration and Nationality Act to deem Khalil removable. Rubio cited the student's involvement in what he characterized as antisemitic protests and disruptive activities at Columbia in 2024. Khalil became the first student protester known to be targeted for his pro-Palestinian views under the second Trump administration. The administration has characterized such activism as a threat to U.S. foreign policy interests and argues it has the legal right to deport noncitizens who engage in it.

Khalil's lawyers argue immigration statutes should not prevent noncitizens from seeking federal court review of detention decisions they say are based on First Amendment-protected speech. They have asked the Supreme Court to rule that noncitizens have the right to sue if immigration officials detain them as a reprisal for exercising free speech. Federal appeals courts are split on whether district judges may hear such challenges or whether claims must proceed first through immigration courts run by the U.S. Department of Justice.

Current status and future steps

If the 3rd Circuit's decision stands, Khalil faces re-arrest and deportation. The Board of Immigration Appeals already denied his appeal and issued a final order of removal in April 2026. His fate now hinges on the Supreme Court. At least four of the nine sitting justices must agree to hear his petition for a writ of certiorari. If granted, oral arguments would likely begin a few months later, with a decision probable by the end of the court's term in May or June 2027. The outcome will determine whether Khalil can remain free and could set a precedent defining access to judicial review for noncitizens detained for political speech.

Topics

#Policy

Related coverage

More from Policy