DHS Noncitizen Voter Claims Face Legal and Expert Challenges
The Department of Homeland Security claims thousands of noncitizens are registered to vote, but state officials and researchers dispute the data as lawsuits challenge related ballot-counting efforts ahead of the 2026 election.

The Department of Homeland Security is claiming widespread noncitizen voter registration, prompting legal challenges and strong pushback from state officials. DHS announced on July 16 that about 278,000 noncitizens were registered to vote in federal elections, later specifying roughly 250,000 across Nevada, California, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. The agency stated it is laser focused on prosecuting and removing aliens who vote to prevent the dilution of votes of U.S. citizens. Its Homeland Security Investigations unit says it is actively investigating election fraud to restore integrity to election systems under President Trump.
Federal courts are rejecting administration attempts to invalidate ballots tied to alleged noncitizen registrations. The Justice Department sued California on October 15 to stop the state from counting mail ballots sent to about 20,000 people it calls likely noncitizens. A federal appeals court rejected the bid to force California to set aside those ballots. The Trump administration's appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court was rejected on Monday. In a separate action, the Justice Department subpoenaed employees of the Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder to appear in court with documents related to noncitizen claims. Nevada Secretary of State Cisco Aguilar said the Justice Department has not filed a lawsuit in his state and does not believe one would succeed. He described the administration's actions as a tactic driven by fear of election outcomes.
State officials dispute DHS data and emphasize procedural safeguards
Nevada's top election official is challenging the DHS figures while emphasizing that registration errors do not prove unlawful voting. DHS initially claimed in July that up to 15,903 noncitizens were registered to vote in Nevada. It later told Aguilar's office it had identified 185 potential noncitizens, calling the initial figure a ceiling. At Nevada's request, DHS provided a list of 6,218 individuals with the highest number of matching attributes to an alien in its records, narrowed from a list of nearly 2.3 million registered voters. Appearing on a voter roll is not the same as casting a ballot. An erroneous registration does not automatically establish that the person personally claimed to be a citizen.
Noncitizens are prohibited from voting under state and federal law. Federal immigration law makes a noncitizen deportable for voting in violation of any voting restriction. A separate provision addresses false claims to U.S. citizenship made for a purpose or benefit, including to register to vote. A criminal conviction is not required for the government to issue a Notice to Appear alleging either ground. Those are government allegations, not final findings by an immigration judge. USCIS guidance states that when a noncitizen is registered, the person bears the burden of showing the form did not ask about citizenship or that they did not indicate U.S. citizenship in response.
Research shows noncitizen voting is exceptionally rare
Independent studies contradict administration claims of widespread fraud. Research organizations, including the Brennan Center for Justice, have found noncitizen voting to be extremely rare. The Heritage Foundation lists roughly 100 cases of noncitizen voting nationwide. President Trump has repeatedly pushed claims that noncitizens are voting in large numbers and helping Democrats cheat.
In many states, voter registration is offered during a driver’s license or state identification card application. A noncitizen may later discover a registration they did not intend. Noncitizens who are unsure can check their status through their state election office. If a registration appears in error, contacting the state or local election office promptly to correct or cancel it is critical. Retain copies of the inquiry, any underlying application, the correction request, and the office’s confirmation. Correction does not necessarily erase a prior false claim, but it can help document what happened. Do not cast a ballot simply because a registration record arrived. Anyone who has already registered or voted while a noncitizen should seek individualized immigration advice before making statements about the matter. An unexpected voter registration should be investigated, not ignored.





