DHS Proposes Ending Deference for H-1B and Other Visa Extensions
The Department of Homeland Security has proposed a rule to eliminate the regulatory requirement that USCIS officers defer to prior approvals when adjudicating extension petitions for H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, and E visa holders.

The U.S. Department of Homeland Security has proposed eliminating the regulatory requirement that officers defer to prior approvals when reviewing repeat extension petitions for the same worker and employer. The proposed rule would remove 8 C.F.R. § 214.1(c)(5), a required starting point that currently guides how officers treat earlier approvals in repeat filings for nonimmigrant workers. Adjudicators could still consider previous approvals but would no longer be required to give those determinations special weight.
DHS argues that each petition should be adjudicated independently. "Each petitioner, applicant or beneficiary must establish eligibility for each immigration benefit request," the department said. Under that rationale, a prior approval would not itself carry the case forward, though the underlying eligibility tests would stay the same.
Current standard provides predictability for unchanged employment
Under the existing framework, an officer generally gives weight to a prior approval when a new Form I-129 involves the same parties and facts. The officer may reach a different result only after finding a material error, a material change in circumstances, or new material information that harms eligibility. That approach can make an extension more predictable when the job duties, worksite, wage, and employee’s qualifications have stayed substantially the same. For many years, USCIS generally deferred to prior eligibility determinations when adjudicating extension petitions involving the same employer, employee, and underlying facts.
Change would shift burden of proof to petitioners in every filing
DHS proposes removing the paragraph and reserving it, rather than substituting a new deference standard. If finalized, the rule would require employers and workers to re-establish eligibility from scratch each time, even without material changes to the employment arrangement. The change would cover Form I-129 extension petitions across multiple employment categories.
| Visa Categories Affected |
|---|
| H-1B |
| L-1 |
| O-1 |
| TN |
| E |
If the proposal takes effect, an extension could receive scrutiny closer to a new petition. Officers could revisit issues accepted in earlier cases, including whether a position still qualifies as a specialty occupation, the employer-employee relationship, and the offered wage alongside actual payroll records. The review could also reach maintenance of status and compliance with the approved petition’s terms. According to DHS, the change is intended to reinforce the petitioner’s burden of proof for every filing, encourage independent review, reduce the risk of perpetuating prior adjudicative errors, and strengthen program integrity.
Impact expected on RFEs, processing times, and costs
Immigration attorneys and industry analysts anticipate more Requests for Evidence, slower decisions, greater variation among officers, and increased legal and administrative expenses. One estimate puts the potential increase at more than 6,000 additional RFEs annually, though it is an estimate and not a final agency projection. They also expect added risk in cases with older job descriptions, changed worksites or wages, mergers, layoffs, or imperfect status records.
Workers filing a third or fourth extension may face particular pressure if they are waiting for employment-based green-card processing and rely on continued H-1B status. Employers can prepare by assembling a well-supported record for an extension petition. This includes detailed current job duties, recent pay statements and payroll records, LCA and wage records, evidence the business continues to operate, the worker’s credentials, and earlier approval notices with an explanation of developments since the last approval.
Comment period underway, implementation timeline unclear
The proposed rule is scheduled for publication in the Federal Register on October 14, 2026. The rule will be subject to a 60-day public comment period, which is expected to close around November 13, 2026. DHS’s proposal would not automatically revoke or reopen existing approvals. It also sets no final implementation date, transition period, or grace period. Those terms remain undecided unless included in a later final rule.
The move represents another shift in a long-running policy debate. During President Trump’s first term, USCIS moved away from broad deference and instructed officers to conduct more independent reviews of extension petitions. The policy was later formally incorporated into federal regulations as part of the H-1B modernization rule that took effect in 2025. In 2021, the Biden administration restored the deference policy through agency guidance, citing consistency and predictability for employers and foreign national workers. The public comment period is expected to close around November 13, 2026, after which DHS will review feedback before deciding whether to finalize the rule.





